You either love or despise Lucas and Peyton.
Brooke should have ended up with Chase.
Nathan and Haley shouldn’t have gotten married so early in the show.
Lucas was the better Scott brother.
Karen and Andy were a better couple than Karen and Keith.
Lucas and Peyton’s exit was the best thing that happened to the show.
Rachel should have been the one to die instead of Keith.
Peyton and Lucas were actually an awful couple.
Nicki wasn’t as horrible as everyone made her out to be.
Peyton and Brooke should have ended up together.
Haley and Lucas should have dated.
Peyton and Jake’s relationship was unhealthy.
Lindsey was the best match for Lucas.
Dan didn’t deserve a redemption arc.
Haley and Brooke had a better friendship than Brooke and Peyton.
The whole Nanny Carrie storyline was too ridiculous and shouldn’t have happened.
Chris Keller didn’t deserve the blame for Nathan and Haley’s breakup in Season 2.
Brooke and Lucas shouldn’t have gotten back together in Season 3.
Mouth was an unlikable character.
Anna should have stayed on the show longer.
Nathan and Brooke should have dated.
Lucas was a horrible person.
Bevin should have been a main character.
Haley and Felix would have made a good couple.
Lucas and Peyton were always meant to be.
Rachel deserved a redemption arc.
People give Nathan too much credit.
And finally, Peyton should have ended up with Jake, and Lucas should have ended up with Brooke.
Note: Submissions have been edited for length and/or clarity.